Side-by-Side 3PL Comparison Services

Stop comparing apples to oranges. Get clear, comprehensive 3PL provider comparisons that make decision-making simple.

Compare 3PL Providers Now

Why 3PL Comparison Is So Difficult

Common Challenges

  • Different pricing structures that can't be compared

  • Missing information in proposals

  • Hidden fees and unclear terms

  • Apples-to-oranges service comparisons

  • No standardized evaluation framework

The Cost

  • Months of back-and-forth with providers

  • Risk of choosing the wrong partner

  • Lost revenue during extended search

  • Potential for costly surprises after signing

Scout's Proven 3PL Comparison Methodology

  • We craft comprehensive RFQs that ensure you get complete, comparable information from every provider.

  • We follow up on unclear items, missing details, and inconsistencies before you ever see the proposals.

  • We translate different pricing structures into apples-to-apples comparisons.

  • You receive a clear comparison matrix covering:

    • Total cost breakdown

    • Service capabilities

    • Technology and integration

    • Geographic coverage

    • Scalability options

    • Implementation timeline

  • Based on your priorities, we provide expert guidance on the best-fit provider.

What We Compare

Evaluation Criteria Provider A Provider B Provider C
Pricing ✓ Detailed ✓ Detailed ✓ Detailed
Monthly base fees $X,XXX $X,XXX $X,XXX
Per-order fees $X.XX $X.XX $X.XX
Storage costs $X.XX/pallet $X.XX/pallet $X.XX/pallet
Services
Order fulfillment ✓ ✓ ✓
Kitting services ✓ ✗ ✓
Returns management ✓ ✓ Limited
Technology
WMS system System A System B Custom
Integration options API + EDI API only EDI only
Real-time tracking ✓ ✓ ✗

*This is a simplified example. Our actual comparisons cover 20+ evaluation criteria.

What You Receive

📊 Comparison Matrix

Comprehensive side-by-side analysis in easy-to-read format

📋 Executive Summary

Our expert recommendations based on your priorities

📈 Cost Analysis

Total cost projections at different volume scenarios

🔍 Detailed Reports

Full analysis of each provider's strengths and considerations

Real Results from 3PL Comparison

Challenge

Jay Franco & Sons, a leading home textiles manufacturer, needed a Canadian 3PL partner to support its growing distribution needs. Their internal process - researching options, comparing pricing, and coordinating site visits - was time-consuming and burdensome. Managing multiple touch points across different providers made it difficult to get a clear, side-by-side comparison, and previously-used brokers lacked the insight and support required to make a fast, confident decision.

Solution

Scout provided a streamlined, personalized facility search process. Acting as a single point of contact, Scout curated a detailed side-by-side comparison of qualified 3PL facilities, complete with profiles and market insights. This eliminated the need for Jay Franco’s team to juggle multiple negotiations and gave leadership the clarity and confidence to choose the right partner quickly.

Results

  • Significant time savings for internal teams

  • Clear side-by-side comparisons enabled confident decision-making

  • Simplified communications with a single point of contact

  • Accelerated project timeline with expert market guidance

Read Other Case Studies

How Our Comparison Service Works

  • No cost to businesses seeking 3PL services

  • We're compensated by providers in our network

  • Our comparisons remain objective and comprehensive

  • You make the final decision—we provide the clarity

Get Your 3PL Comparison Started

Let's start with a free consultation to understand your needs and show you how our sourcing process works.

Email us: hello@scoutsupplychain.ca

Call Dave: 778.551.3484
Call Jeff: 604.220.1515

Or book a time with Dave or Jeff.