Side-by-Side 3PL Comparison Services

Stop comparing apples to oranges. Get clear, comprehensive 3PL provider comparisons that make decision-making simple.

Compare 3PL Providers Now

Why 3PL Comparison Is So Difficult

Common Challenges

  • Different pricing structures that can't be compared

  • Missing information in proposals

  • Hidden fees and unclear terms

  • Apples-to-oranges service comparisons

  • No standardized evaluation framework

The Cost

  • Months of back-and-forth with providers

  • Risk of choosing the wrong partner

  • Lost revenue during extended search

  • Potential for costly surprises after signing

Scout's Proven 3PL Comparison Methodology

  • We craft comprehensive RFQs that ensure you get complete, comparable information from every provider.

  • We follow up on unclear items, missing details, and inconsistencies before you ever see the proposals.

  • We translate different pricing structures into apples-to-apples comparisons.

  • You receive a clear comparison matrix covering:

    • Total cost breakdown

    • Service capabilities

    • Technology and integration

    • Geographic coverage

    • Scalability options

    • Implementation timeline

  • Based on your priorities, we provide expert guidance on the best-fit provider.

What We Compare

Evaluation Criteria Provider A Provider B Provider C
Pricing ✓ Detailed ✓ Detailed ✓ Detailed
Monthly base fees $X,XXX $X,XXX $X,XXX
Per-order fees $X.XX $X.XX $X.XX
Storage costs $X.XX/pallet $X.XX/pallet $X.XX/pallet
Services
Order fulfillment ✓ ✓ ✓
Kitting services ✓ ✗ ✓
Returns management ✓ ✓ Limited
Technology
WMS system System A System B Custom
Integration options API + EDI API only EDI only
Real-time tracking ✓ ✓ ✗

*This is a simplified example. Our actual comparisons cover 20+ evaluation criteria.

What You Receive

📊 Comparison Matrix

Comprehensive side-by-side analysis in easy-to-read format

📋 Executive Summary

Our expert recommendations based on your priorities

📈 Cost Analysis

Total cost projections at different volume scenarios

🔍 Detailed Reports

Full analysis of each provider's strengths and considerations

Real Results from 3PL Comparison

Challenge

U.S.-based Equity Brands needed to enter the Canadian market but lacked a local fulfillment partner, facing high shipping costs and slow delivery. With a tight launch deadline and past negative experiences with 3PLs, they needed to quickly find a trusted partner to hold inventory in Canada.

Solution

Equity Brands engaged Scout to accelerate their search. Scout immediately matched them with a Vancouver 3PL to meet the launch deadline, later transitioning them to a larger, national provider as they grew. Scout's responsive, expert approach ensured their logistics could scale with their growth.

Results

  • Roughly 65% growth in Canadian sales from 2022–2024

  • Faster shipping times and improved customer satisfaction

  • Lower fulfillment costs and stronger margins

  • Seamless compliance with Canadian retailer requirements

  • Scalable logistics network supporting expansion from 30 SKUs to 100+

Read Other Case Studies

How Our Comparison Service Works

  • No cost to businesses seeking 3PL services

  • We're compensated by providers in our network

  • Our comparisons remain objective and comprehensive

  • You make the final decision—we provide the clarity

Get Your 3PL Comparison Started

Let's start with a free consultation to understand your needs and show you how our sourcing process works.

Email us: hello@scoutsupplychain.ca

Call Dave: 778.551.3484
Call Jeff: 604.220.1515

Or book a time with Dave or Jeff.